Shared Laughter: A Missing Vital Sign
Has shared laughter gone into hiding? Shared laughter has become a stranger to our nation and the church. I miss the merry heart, spoken of in Proverbs 17. Expressions of common joy are secluded, perhaps kidnapped or a part of a gaiety-witness-protection-program buried underground somewhere. Shared laughter, healing laughter, earnest and sustained laughter, seems hard to find.
I still laugh, but too often alone… or with people who think much like me. Such singular pleasure is a place to begin. Small signs of whimsy, mirth and delight are starting places. When I miss those, I quickly get lost in my prejudices and despair. I lose the lightheartedness that can serve as a lubricant to God’s desired wholeheartedness for me. A little laughter keeps my ideological GPS in tune and my prejudice-constructed life-maps from being read upside down. Recently I had a reminder of such a gift.
On a winding road in central Kentucky, the junction ahead at first confused me, then delighted. I could turn left and go NORTH or turn right and go… uh… NORTH. And the path straight ahead (NORTH by the way) was posted with a NO TRESPASSING sign.
If I wished to go NORTH, which way should I go? I laughed out loud. This reminded me of the certainty as to direction I hear from pundits and preachers who speak confidently of the only true way forward — their way. Traveling this day and familiar with this particular road, I knew the path I would take. I wondered about others who followed, who arrive at this junction — first timers.
I believe the certainty, that there is only one way, a best and only road ahead puts the nation, and the church, in hands of humorless demagogues. For our nation such certainty means that every choice is binary with no ability to value and learn from those who have different perspectives or life experiences. Any sense of a commonweal is set aside. In the church such certainty turns the theological task into a marshaling of doctrinaire pronouncements. Instead of theology being “faith in search of understanding” we have one narrow set of understandings setting the limits of our faith. Not much shared joy here. I believe laughter can be medicine for the soul and oxygen for a suffocating nation and church.
On my wall is Wendell Berry’s poem, Manifesto: The Mad Farmer Liberation Front. Near the end, he counsels, “Laugh. Laughter is immeasurable. Be joyful even when you have considered all the facts.”
I am asking what has happened to shared laughter — among friends and with those who disagree? I don’t mean the little individual chuckles coming from late-night television parodies or the smile after reading ironic memes about the state of the nation. I mean the sense of well-being that is born of a shared hope beyond our calculations. What I miss is the ability to laugh at ourselves, to visit with others who may hold differing opinions and enjoy each other’s company. It is the joy of discourse and community that is creative and constructive and larger than our personal prejudices and proclivities. Laughter is not sufficient for our salvation but I believe it may be a necessary vestibule to hope and renewal in finding a way forward.
Aimee Laramore writing in the March 7, 2018 blog Voices on Stewardship helps me when she writes, “The great theologian Dave Chappelle introduced a concept that made me laugh out loud when he spoke about imperfect allies. In his most recent special, he offers a poignant description of not understanding some of the differences in societal demographics and ended with his personal truth on the matter. Is it possible in our faith communities to be honest about the things we don’t understand? He repeatedly said, “I don’t want to harm you. I want to support you. I just don’t understand you.” I believe we should do a lot more earnest laughing about our own discomfort about diversity in giving. At the very least, a heartfelt response is authentic.”
Much more shared EARNEST LAUGHING with IMPERFECT ALLIES is called for in the nation and church. In these time of “Fake News,” made-up statistics and certainties that avoid scientific evidence, we might look again to the realism of theologian Reinhold Niebuhr. In response to the horrors and potential devastation from threats of fascism he wrote “Laughter is the no-man’s land between cynicism and contrition.” In his Children of Light, Children of Darkness, Niebuhr argues “Humour is, in fact, a prelude to faith; and laughter is the beginning of prayer… Laughter is swallowed up in prayer and humour is fulfilled by faith.”
In an effort to offer something constructive for churches (and our society) I recently wrote a paper on what I see as the mistaken, and humorless efforts to repair the church by implementing certain business practices. This is a well-meaning effort but of little purchase if it simply is composed of one perspective, outside of dialogue with those who view the church differently (see: FruitFixPubShare02-01-18). My long and rather tedious musings needed the benefit of EARNEST LAUGHTER WITH IMPERFECT ALLIES.
I did find a chuckle when I read a quote from St. Louis area United Methodist pastor Diana Kenaston who captured my paper’s conclusions when she wrote:
“So we look at statistics and we call them ‘vital signs.’ We commission a report and draw an electrocardiogram on the front.”
In two sentences, Rev. Kenaston covered what took sixteen pages and forty-nine footnotes for me to say… and this without ever reading my paper! I LAUGHED.
I knew my research paper was insufficient. (Even so, I inflicted it upon many friends and my students.) Reading Diana’s quote helped. However, some other uncommon laughter was needed. Some candor from imperfect allies might help. The ability to learn of my mistaken understandings, and laugh with those who had another view, might help each. Until then I don’t believe much progress is made.
Might I sit with those who disagree and talk, and learn? Might we make a common alliance to agree to disagree? Until then, good as any research might be, it would be of modest value. Yes, I have reached out to my imperfect allies — several times asking to hear from them. Might those who offer their products, known as “fruitful congregation” initiatives be open to dialogue that might lead to understanding? As yet, no response to my multiple requests. Still waiting. Even more, I am eager to experience a little shared laughter.
Until then, or even if such shared conversation never arrives, I am helped by the poetry of the fourteenth-century Dominican mystic Meister Eckhart. He gives me a joy-filled perspective at this junction for our society and church.
Do you want to know
what goes on in the core of the Trinity?
I will tell you.
In the core of the Trinity
The Father laughs
and gives birth to the Son.
The Son laughs back at the Father
and gives birth to the Spirit.
The whole Trinity laughs
and gives birth to us.
[Meister Eckhart, Meditations with Meister Eckhart, translation and editor Matthew Fox (Bear and Company: 1983), p. 129.
6 thoughts on “Shared Laughter: A Missing Vital Sign”
As Rumi says, “There are many ways to the Divine. I have chosen the ways of song, dance, and laughter.”
I suggest we put that in the Bible verbatim. Just sayin’, Ann
LikeLiked by 1 person
When I reread my earlier blogs, I can hardly remember being so chirpy and upbeat. The political climate has changed since then. It’s hard to imagine Old Testament prophets, who saw where the faithlessness of the Israelites led, sitting on a rock and guffawing–over anything. If laughter generates hope, I’m stuck in this mental quagmire. Thanks, anyway, Phil.
Author of “Had Eve Come First and Jonah Been a Woman”
LikeLiked by 1 person
Thanks Nancy. I think I am with you. Didn’t mean to say that laughter will generate hope, nor was this a call to quietism. It is my current alternative to crying or enraged shouting to an empty conversation table. Perhaps it’s a prayer or a search for a bit of shared lightheartedness that MIGHT lead to conversation. Never seen a time like this when folks with whom I differed politically or theologically simply disappeared from dialogue.
Thanks for quoting my “Holy Contradictions” essay — it made me laugh to be quoted alongside Wendell Berry, Reinhold Niebuhr, and Dave Chappelle! I’ll go read your article now…
LikeLiked by 1 person
Glad to include you among the saints! You might wait to read my article until bedtime. I will help you to sleep. See that you heading to University Church. Tom Frank is a longtime friend… and many other connections I suspect.
Tom Frank was one of my seminary mentors, so it delighted me to follow his footsteps here! After several years with University UMC, I can re-read “The Soul of a Congregation” with much amusement. #smallmethodistworld
Comments are closed.